Against The Grain 2027 – Judging Criteria

Functional & Furniture 

This category celebrates practical pieces like tables, chairs, cabinets, and other functional items.

Functionality and Usability

  • Does the piece effectively serve its intended function (e.g. comfort for seating, storage capacity for cabinets)?
  • Is it practical, ergonomic, and user-friendly?
  • Are there design features that enhance usability (e.g. smooth drawer slides, soft-close hinges)?

Structural Integrity

  • Does the construction demonstrate strength and durability?
  • Is the piece stable and balanced (e.g. does it wobble or tilt)?
  • Do the joinery methods used contribute to long-term durability?

Craftsmanship

  • Are joints and assembly methods (e.g. dovetails, mortise and tenon) executed with precision?
  • Is there consistency in shaping, sanding, and finishing, especially in visible areas?
  • Are there any visible gaps, rough edges, or inconsistencies?

Design and Proportion

  • Does the piece maintain overall balance, symmetry, and proportion?
  • Is there aesthetic harmony between different design elements (e.g. size, scale, and proportion)?

Material Choice

  • Is the wood species chosen appropriate for durability and aesthetics?
  • Are materials used in an innovative or sustainable manner?
  • Does the finish enhance or protect the material effectively?

    Artistic & Ornamental

    Focus on decorative and creative pieces like carvings, sculptures, instruments and ornamental designs.

    Artistic Expression

    • Does the piece showcase originality and creativity?
    • Does it tell a story or evoke emotion?
    • How effectively does the piece use composition, contrast, or form to create an impact?

    Detailing and Precision

    • Are carvings, inlays, or other decorative techniques executed with precision?
    • Is the detailing consistent throughout with no rough or unfinished areas?
    • Are fine details crisp and intentional rather than accidental?

    Design Aesthetics

    • Is there harmony between shapes, patterns, and overall visual appeal?
    • Are there innovative or unexpected design elements that enhance the piece?

    Material and Finish

    • Does the choice of materials enhance the artistic impact (e.g., grain selection, color contrast)?
    • Is the surface treatment and finishing of high quality, with no streaks, blotches, or inconsistencies?

    Impact and Presentation

    • Does the piece create a strong visual and emotional impact (the "wow factor")?
    • How effectively is the piece displayed or mounted?
    • Does the presentation enhance the overall aesthetic or theme?

      Australian Woodturning

      A revival of the classic event, this category is dedicated to any lathe-based creations, including bowls, vases, spindles, and other turned pieces.

      Turning Skill

      • Are curves and transitions smooth and well-executed?
      • Is there precision and control in achieving symmetry or intentional asymmetry?
      • Are there any visible tool marks, catches, or tear-outs?

      Form and Proportion

      • Does the piece maintain balance and harmony in its shape?
      • Are the proportions appropriate for the type of piece (e.g. bowl, vase, or spindle)?
      • Does the piece present well from different viewing angles?

      Surface Quality

      • Is the surface smooth, with no tool marks or inconsistencies?
      • Has the sanding and polishing been done to a high standard?

      Material and Finish

      • Does the wood grain, natural imperfections, or patterns enhance the design?
      • Is the finishing consistent and of high quality (e.g. lacquer, oil, or wax)?

      Creativity and Innovation

      • Does the piece incorporate unique or unconventional forms or techniques?
      • Are there additional creative elements, such as segmented turning, inlays, or texturing?